A week after the news broke, one longtime customer stopped by Village Ace Hardware on Orange Avenue to say goodbye. Owner Glenn Shirer was behind the counter. In a letter to the Coronado Eagle & Journal, the customer wrote, "I have always had keys made there," and asked passersby to "stop by and say hello, and maybe there is something there you might just need."
Village Ace is expected to close by December 31, 2026. After that, Coronado will have one full hardware store, Coronado Hardware Glass & Paint at 140 Orange Avenue. How that store has stayed open says a lot about what island hardware will look like in 2027.
What leaves the 900 block at year's end
According to the Eagle & Journal's October report, Village Ace has served Coronado for more than three decades. Shirer has run it since its early days and is now retiring. The article lists what the store covered: hand tools, fasteners, paint matching, lawn and garden supplies, outdoor living products and key cutting. It also describes the place itself, with original wooden floors, tall aisles, open bins of nuts and bolts, and classic gum machines by the door.
For the rest of this month and December, Ace lists the store at 949 Orange Ave., open 8 a.m. to 6 p.m. every day, phone (619) 672-1948. Shirer and his staff plan to keep serving customers right up to the closing date.
That leaves the paint counter and the bins of loose fasteners as the services residents will need to find somewhere else. The obvious next stop is a few hundred numbers up Orange Avenue, at a store that took a very different route decades ago.
The store that stays rebuilt its shelves after 1999
When the Perkins-Hammett family bought Coronado Hardware in 1987, it was a standard hardware store, according to a 2024 Eagle & Journal profile. In 1999, Pam Hammett's brother and partner, Joe Perkins, moved away, and Phil and Pam Hammett bought the store. Phil had worked as a contractor before going into retail. Pam had majored in marketing and banking.
They added new products, and some longtime staff saw no need for the "frivolous items" showing up on the shelves. The same profile tells how one salesman ended that debate:
"Okay, I get it. A lady came in to buy a screw and left with a $50 bag of merchandise."
Walk in today and you will pass souvenirs, gifts, beach accessories and kitchen items on the way to the glass, paint, lumber and buckets. The counter at the back carries postcards, children's toys and paper flower bouquets for mailing. The profile calls the traditional hardware the store's main staple. The smaller items in view of the open door are what bring in walkers and tourists on their way to nearby restaurants. Pam Hammett and her friend Marnie Fledderjohn buy the non-construction goods.
So the visitor who stops in for a bamboo cutting board helps keep a store stocked with fasteners and glass for the homeowner fixing a cabinet hinge.
A Wednesday order and a Monday truck
The gift shelves explain how the store makes money. A co-op explains how it can carry so much in so little space. Coronado Hardware joined Do it Best as the big chains started to hurt smaller retailers. Through the co-op, the store can buy single items at competitive prices from a warehouse of more than 70,000 products.
The 2024 profile describes how it works. If an item isn't on the shelf, a customer describes it to a salesperson. The order goes out Wednesday and the truck arrives Monday, so the item usually shows up within a few days. The store's website also offers free shipping to the store on any Do it Best online order, with no obligation to buy.
This matters once Village Ace closes. A store of Ace's size kept a lot of stock on the floor. Coronado Hardware keeps the staples on hand and gets the rest through the co-op's warehouse, so for a specific part, a Wednesday order may get it to Orange Avenue before a weekend project.
The contractor counter behind the gift shelves
Coronado Hardware has a third line of business. According to the Eagle & Journal profile, Phil Hammett and store manager Greg Gredvig install windows and doors, supply materials to other contractors and do-it-yourself homeowners, and take pride in retrofitting older homes. The store's website lists Anlin and TM Cobb windows for new builds and renovations, with a separate estimate line at (619) 857-9966.
Each piece supports the others: the gift shelves bring people in the door, the co-op gives a small floor plan a huge catalog, and the window and door work earns money that doesn't depend on walk-in traffic on a slow afternoon.
Where the smaller errands go
Village Ace's paint matching and loose-hardware bins move to the store described above. Coronado Hardware's posted hours are 8 a.m. to 6 p.m. Monday through Saturday and 10 a.m. to 4 p.m. Sunday, with parking behind the building. For other errands:
- Key copies: A KeyMe kiosk sits along the front wall inside Vons at 868 Orange Ave. and copies home and office keys. It is listed as available from 6 a.m. to 11 p.m. daily.
- Locksmith work: Coronado Lock and Key is listed at 1016 9th St.
- An Ace store off the island: Ace's locator lists Downtown Ace Hardware at 675 6th Ave. in San Diego, plus Hillcrest Ace at 1003 University Ave.
What comes next at 949 Orange
Village Ace will leave a 2,444-square-foot space open. Urban Property Group represents the property and expects it to be available for lease in early 2027. The firm is inviting interest from "retail, hospitality, and creative concepts." Hardware isn't named on that list. Whoever signs the lease will decide what the 900 block becomes, and the pitch is aimed at tenants other than a second hardware store.
Other changes on the street are already underway. Charleston Shoe Company closed its Orange Avenue store last summer and donated its remaining shoes to the Sharp Coronado Hospital Auxiliary's Holiday Fair. In October, the City Council authorized bids for Phase 1 of the Orange Avenue Downtown Enhancement, which covers new benches, bins and other street furnishings. A contract is expected in December, and staff anticipate construction starting in late April 2027, according to the Eagle & Journal's council coverage.
This evening at 140 Orange
The Coronado Chamber of Commerce holds its November networking mixer today, Thursday, November 19, from 4:30 to 6 p.m. Coronado Hardware Glass & Paint is hosting, with light bites and a drink, per the Chamber's event listing. The Hammetts are no strangers to local organizations. Their website lists memberships in the Chamber, the Coronado Schools Foundation and Coronado Rotary, plus support for Coronado Youth Soccer, Coronado Little Leagues and the Islander Sports Foundation. Their daughter, Michelle Munns, owns Taste of Coronado, the organizer of the village food walk we wrote about this fall.
Village Ace expects to keep its doors open until the end of December, which leaves time to thank Glenn Shirer in person before he retires.
At The Clements Group, we follow Orange Avenue storefronts as closely as we follow the homes around them, including who moves into 949 Orange next year. If you're planning repairs, a window retrofit or getting a home ready to sell, schedule a private consultation and we'll talk through the local resources that help along the way.